This Week's PCR Movie Review |
"Brokeback Mountain"
Movie review by: Movies are rated 0 to 4 stars
|
LA FLORIDIANA The History of Miami International Airport -- Part Three....2005 Index by Will Moriaty Also see This issue's La Fla supplemental piece | ||
THIS WEEK'S MOVIE REVIEW "Brokeback Mountain" by Mike Smith | ||
DEADGUY'S DEMENTIA Walking the Fine Line... by Mike "Deadguy" Scott | ||
COUCH POTATO CONFESSIONS Wow, 2005 Really Did Exist!...Finally Getting Their Just Due....A Thought for 2006 by Vinnie Blesi | ||
THE AUDIO PHILES The Top 20 Albums of 2005 by Terence Nuzum | ||
MY MIDDLE TOE One New Life by Mark Terry | ||
BLACK DOG BITES BACK The Beginning and the End: Ups and Downs From The Year 2005 .... Gaming .... Politics by Joshua Montgomery | ||
NICHOLAS REX The Top 10 Things That Pissed Me Off In 2005 by Nick King | ||
MIKE'S RANT Hello Gang....Internet Troubles! by Mike Smith | ||
Archives of Nolan's Pop Culture Review | ||
Archives 2005 Archives 2004 Archives 2003 Archives 2002 Archives 2001 Archives 2000 Email PCR |
Home |
If you've heard of the film "Brokeback Mountain," you've probably heard the words "gay cowboy movie" in the mention. But that is such a slight. Yes, the two main characters are cowboys. And, yes, the two do carry on a secret affair for 20-plus years. But in between their times together is a story about secret love and the tragedies it can bring.
In 1963, Jack Twist (Gyllenhall) and Ennis Del mar (Ledger) apply for work as sheep tenders for rancher Joe Aguirre (Quaid). Aguirre tells them they will be spending the next few months up on Brokeback Mountain. One is to stay in the camp and the other to sleep among the sheep each night to prevent them from being rustled. One night a storm catches them both in camp. Jack goes to his tent but Ennis decides to rough it outside. As the temperature drops, Jack invites Ennis to come huddle for warmth. Soon the huddling turns to cuddling. The next morning, as he rides out to the sheep, Ennis tells Jack that what happened was just a one shot thing. However, as the summer turns into fall, they find themselves building on a relationship neither of them thought was possible. Jack begins talking about the two of them starting their own ranch but Ennis knows that can never happen. When he was younger, he witnessed a rancher beaten to death by others because of his suspected lifestyle. He tells Jack, "if this thing grabs hold of us at the wrong place, wrong time...we're dead."
When the season ends, Jack and Ennis go their own way. Ennis to Wyoming, where he works on ranches and Jack to Texas, where he rides bulls. They both have gotten married and started families. Life seems good. A postcard from Jack finds Ennis and they meet to go fishing. There they talk about where they are now. Ennis seems happy and is proud of his daughters. Jack's father in law is very rich and very pompous. He feels his daughter has married beneath her station and insists on calling Jack "rodeo." As their fishing weekend ends they both realize that a connection was made all those years ago. As time goes on, things change. Ennis' wife, Alma (Williams) suspects he and Jack are more then just fishing buddies and divorces him. Jack again tries to convince Ennis to start a ranch but he is reluctant to do anything that will draw attention to them, fearful of retribution. As time passes, it's obvious that love is hard to handle, no matter who you are.
Credit director Ang Lee with taking what could have been a very stereotypical story and crafting a true love story. As I mentioned earlier, this is a love story full of tragedies. If Jack and Ennis were teenagers they would be Romeo and Juliet. If they were American and Puerto Rican, they would be Tony and Maria in "West Side Story." The fact that they are both men is really second to the true story. And it is that story that makes the film one of the best this year. The cast is excellent all around. Both Williams and Hathaway portray wives that don't understand the bond their husbands have. But while Ennis is all Alma has, Jack's wife has her father's money to occupy her time. Gyllenhall adds this performance to his work in "Jarhead" to announce his arrival as a first rate actor. But the star here is Ledger. Speaking in a low tone through constantly clenched teeth, Ennis is a man who's afraid to love. Be it his wife or his friend, the fear is there, and Ledger captures that fear perfectly. The photography is outstanding. The film looks like a series of postcards taken at the height of natures beauty, with each scene adding a perfect backdrop to the story.
A love story told this well is something that should be seen and appreciated. Whether it's a man and a woman, a dog and cat or even two cowboys, a great story is hard to resist. On a scale of zero to four stars I give "Brokeback Mountain"
This week's movie review of "Brokeback Mountain" is ©2005 by Michael A. Smith. All graphics this page are creations of Nolan B. Canova, ©2005, all rights reserved. All contents of "Nolan's Pop Culture Review" are ©2005 by Nolan B. Canova.